da HRWF
HRWF (29.05.2020) -
Cocin Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet ba shi da kyakkyawan suna a Faransa da Vatican. Tun daga ranar 27 ga Fabrairun 1977, lokacin da mutanen da ke da alaƙa da Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) suka mamaye ta da karfi, wanda ba bisa ka'ida ba, wannan cocin shine babban wurin ibada ga ƙungiyoyin Katolika na gargajiya a Paris. Kotu sun ba da umarnin korar, amma ba a taba aiwatar da su ba. An ce taron a cikin Latin kuma an hana sabbin gyare-gyaren zamani na Cocin Roman Katolika a Majalisar Vatican II (1962-1965). COVID-19 ya ba da kyakkyawar dama ga wasu kafofin watsa labarai don bata sunan wannan cocin mai gardama ta hanyar amfani da hanyoyi da mahawara. An fara ne a ranar Ista Lahadi.
Tasirin wasan ƙwallon ƙanƙara da haɓakawa Lahadi 12 Afrilu 2020 (Easter), AFP-La Croix/Covid 19: taron Ista na ɓoye a cikin cocin Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet.
Karkashin taken wannan sanarwar manema labarai na AFP, wanda jaridar La Croix ta yau da kullun ta buga ba tare da wani sharhi ko tabbatarwa ba, ita ce taken: “An yi taron Ista na ɓoye a daren Asabar-Lahadi a cikin Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet na gargajiya. coci a Paris. Membobin cocin sun shiga kuma an ci tarar firist saboda karya ka’idojin tsare.” A cewar wannan sakin,
- 'yan dozin mutane ne suka halarci wani taro a wannan majami'a a gunduma ta 5 a birnin Paris, wadda ke ci gaba da gudanar da bikin a cikin harshen Latin, duk da Vatican II.
- da yammacin ranar Asabar, mazauna yankin sun sanar da ‘yan sanda bayan da suka ji kade-kade da ke fitowa daga cocin
- da tsakar dare, membobin sun fita daga cocin kuma suka shaida wa 'yan sanda cewa akwai kimanin mutane arba'in a ciki
- Jami’an ‘yan sanda sun tuntubi limamin cocin, wanda aka ci tararsa, a cewar wata majiyar ‘yan sandan da ba a tantance ba
- wani faifan bidiyo da aka watsa a YouTube ya nuna kusan malamai talatin da yara suna hidimar jama'a, ba tare da rufe fuska ba kuma ba tare da mutunta ka'idojin nisantar da jama'a ba.
- faifan bidiyon da aka watsa a YouTube ya nuna kusan malamai 30 da yara kanana suna hidimar jama'a, dukkansu ba su da abin rufe fuska ba tare da nuna kyama ba.
- An rarraba eucharist daga hannu zuwa baki ga mahalarta goma sha biyu
- babu masu halarta a cikin coci
Lahadi 12 Afrilu 2020, ofishin 'yan sanda/ Twitter A wannan ranar, shafin Twitter na ofishin 'yan sanda ya karanta: "A daren nan a #Paris05, an gudanar da taron addini a coci duk da matakan tsare mutane. Lokacin da 'yan sanda suka zo don sarrafa shi, an rufe dukkan kofofin. Bayan taro sun ci tarar hukumar cocin da ta jagoranci taron.” Inda da kuma lokacin da za a ci tarar firist ba a ambata a cikin tweet ba. Saƙo mai ban mamaki daga 'yan sanda: Ana iya yin taron jama'a duk da matakan tsare mutane, amma idan mutane ba su shiga ba kuma hakan yana faruwa a bayan kofofin da aka rufe, wanda shine lamarin cocin Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet. A duk manyan coci-coci a Faransa, bishop bishop sun gudanar da bukukuwan Ista a bayan kofa. Bugu da ƙari, ba a cikin ɗabi'ar ƴan sandan Faransa su murkushe cocin Katolika, gidan ibada na Furotesta, masallaci ko majami'a ba.
Lahadi 12 Afrilu 2020, Le Point/Clandestine Ista taro
Har ila yau Le Point ta bayyana cewa an ci tarar 135 ga wani firist. Dole ne a yi mamakin yadda duk wani matakin 'yan sanda zai yiwu idan an rufe kofofin da kuma yadda 'yan sanda suka sanya tarar wani limamin coci a rufe. Bugu da ƙari, Le Point ta buga faifan bidiyo da ke nuna cocin da ke cike da mutane a ciki. Koyaya, wannan hoto ne da aka ajiye kuma ba wai taron maraice na ɓoye na 11 ga Afrilu ba. Haka kuma, shi ma ba hoton allo ba ne. Jean-Luc Mélenchon, shugaban masu kwarjini na ƙungiyar siyasa ta hagu, ya yi amfani da hirarsa a kan shirin RTL-TV na farko "Le Grand Jury" don yin Allah wadai da Katolika. Kwanaki biyu bayan haka, Christophe Castaner, Ministan Harkokin Cikin Gida, ya bayyana a kan France-Inter: “Na yi mamakin bikin wannan taro. Ba laifi wani firist ya riƙe ta.” Duk da cewa an kafa wannan magana a kan labaran karya, wannan minista ba wani ya zagi shi ba. Dole ne a yi tunanin ko zai yi haka, ba tare da wani bincike na farko a kan labarin ba, da a ce game da wata al'umma ta addini.
Talata 14 Afrilu 2020, Le Progrès/Clandestine taro, tarar da aka yi wa masu gargajiya (https://bit.ly/3es37eW)
Wannan labarin ya ba da rahoton cewa lokacin da 'yan sanda suka isa, an rufe kofofin cocin kuma mahalarta sun fice. Don haka ba a ci tarar kowa ba.
Talata 14 Afrilu 2020, Valeurs Actuelles/ Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet, "labarai na karya" da coronavirus: kafofin watsa labarai a cikin rikicin imani mara kyauhttps://bit.ly/3grxDqN)
Uba Danziec, marubuci a Valeurs Actuelles, ya bayyana cewa:
- Tun daga farkon tsare, an buga a gidan yanar gizon coci cewa membobin coci ba za su iya shiga ayyukan addini ba kuma za a yi bikin su kai tsaye ta YouTube.
- Vigil na Ista ba "a ɓoye" ba ne, maimakon haka an yi bikin ne da ƙarfe 10.30 na dare a cikin coci kuma ana watsa shi kai tsaye akan YouTube (ra'ayoyi 26,000 kamar na 14 ga Afrilu).
Laraba 15 ga Afrilu, 2020, taro na Le Point/Clandestine a Paris: 'yan sanda sun ce su bar (https://bit.ly/2M1WzY5)
Kwanaki uku bayan haka, Le Point ta yi tsokaci da wata kasida mai taken: "Taron sirri a Paris: 'yan sanda sun ce su tafi". Wannan ya ba da ra'ayi cewa an kori 'yan sanda daga cocin, a gaskiya ma an rufe shi. A cikin labarin, an ce jami’an sun koma ofishin ‘yan sanda ne bisa umarnin manyansu, wanda a cewar dan jaridar, wani abin nuna sha’awa ne da ba za a iya fahimta ba. Ba tare da wata hujja mai mahimmanci ba, ɗan jaridar ya ci gaba da zarge-zarge, wanda ya ƙarfafa tasirin rubutun nasa:
- kasancewar mahalarta waje yayin hidimar addini, wanda karya ne
- kalaman da ake zargin mahalarta taron sun yi wa jami’an ‘yan sandan da ke bakin fita, wata karyar kuma babu mahalarta da ‘yan sandan za su yi magana da su.
- jin daɗin "marasa fahimta", a cewar ɗan jaridar, ga masu halarta, kamar dai matsayin 'yan sanda ya kasance maras kyau a cikin wannan halin.
- ofishin 'yan sandan ya ce wa Ministan Harkokin Cikin Gida cewa "masu halartar taron sun bar cocin ta wasu hanyoyi" don haka sun guje musu, wanda ba gaskiya ba ne kuma zato ba tare da wata shaida ba.
Mafi muni kuma, ɗan jaridar ya kwatanta faifan bidiyon da aka buga a gidan yanar gizon Le Point a matsayin “mai ban mamaki” shaida na keta ƙa’idodin tsare mutane, ko da yake ya san cewa ba bidiyon hidimar addini na Ista ba ne.
Menene gaskiyar lamarin?
Hotunan da Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet ta rarraba sun yi magana da kansu:
https://twitter.com/MichelJanva/status/1249449549661450250
https://www.lesalonbeige.fr/une-messe-denoncee-par-des-voisins/
Haka kuma, sharhin cocin ya bayyana sunan firist - Petrucci - kuma ya ce ba a taba ci shi tarar ba. Da yammacin ranar Asabar, mazauna yankin da ke kusa da cocin Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet, sun ji wasu kade-kade da ke fitowa daga cikin wurin ibada, suka kuma sanar da ‘yan sanda. An aika jami'an 'yan sanda zuwa cocin, amma an rufe kofofin. Da yake babu wata matsala, sai suka sanar da ofishin ’yan sanda sannan suka umarce su da su dawo. A cikin cocin, an yi bikin Easter ne kawai tare da limaman, wanda aka watsa kai tsaye ta YouTube don mutane su kalla daga gidajensu. Shahararrun kafafen yada labaran Faransa ba su yi kasa a gwiwa ba wajen kai hari kan al’ummar Katolika, ba tare da bayyanannun hujjoji ba, domin al’ada ce ba ta yau da kullun ba. Waɗannan, ba shakka, dalilai ne marasa inganci na zargin coci da laifuffuka na tunani. Bugu da ƙari, yayin da wannan al'ummar ke kawo ƙalubale ga Cocin Roman Katolika, ba abin mamaki ba ne cewa kafofin watsa labaru na Katolika ba su tabbatar da gaskiya ba. Waɗannan jaridun na Faransa: - sun sake buga sanarwar manema labarai na AFP da labarin son zuciya na Le Point, ba tare da wani bincike ko tabbatarwa ba - sun kasa tuntuɓar mai magana da yawun majami'ar Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet don jin sigar labarin nasu- ya ci tura. don yin hira da abbot Petrucci, wanda ke kula da coci- ya yi amfani da ƙamus na wulakanci don kwatanta gaskiyar da ba ta da tushe kamar: taro na ɓoye, cocin da ke cike da mahalarta, rashin fahimtar abin da 'yan sanda suka yi, bidiyo mai ban mamaki, da dai sauransu - ya watsa bidiyon karya na bidiyon. Taron bikin Ista da aka yi zargin an gudanar da shi a cikin cocin a ranar Ista ba tare da yin watsi da hotunan allo da al'ummar cocin da ake zargi suka buga ta yanar gizo ba wanda ke nuna cewa an mutunta matakan kulle-kullen musamman na bukukuwan addini - ba a taba tambayar sahihancin hotunan hoton da aka fada ba. A cikin labarin da ya gabata, Human Rights Ba tare da Frontiers ba (HRWF) ta yi tir da irin wannan matsalar rashin kula da da'ar aikin jarida a cikin lamarin da al'ummar Ikklesiyoyin bishara a Mulhouse (Faransa) suka yi fatali da cutar. (Duba https://hrwf.eu/france-covid-19-scapegoating-an-evangelical-church-in-mulhouse/.)
